AG Rantos proposes annulment of Commission decision finding State aid in Micula arbitration award 

In Joined Cases C-890/24 PP and C-891/24 P AG Rantos proposed that the Court of Justice set aside the General Court’s 2024 judgment and annul the Commission finding that Romania’s payment of compensation under the Micula arbitral award constituted unlawful and incompatible State aid. 

The dispute concerns compensation of around EUR 178 million awarded to the Micula brothers and several companies following Romania’s repeal, before its accession to the EU, of a tax incentives scheme. In 2015, the Commission found that payment of the compensation constituted State aid and ordered its recovery. The General Court initially annulled that decision, but its judgment was subsequently set aside by the Court of Justice and, following referral back, the General Court dismissed the actions for annulment in 2024. 

The AG considered that the General Court erred in law in its assessment of the economic advantage criterion. In particular, he questioned the finding that the State aid advantage arose only when Romania implemented or paid the arbitral award. He noted that the Court of Justice had previously held that the right to compensation was created by the arbitral award itself.  

He further considered that the Asteris case-law, which distinguishes State aid from compensation for damage suffered, was relevant. According to the AG, the arbitral tribunal based the compensation on Romania’s failure to ensure fair and equitable treatment under the bilateral investment treaty, rather than simply on the non-payment of the tax incentives. He also noted that the damages awarded did not necessarily correspond to the economic consequences of withdrawing those incentives. 

Importantly, the AG also considered that the reasoning in DOBELES HES may be transposed to arbitral awards. In that judgment, the Court held that the establishment of State aid entails a decision as to the appropriate course of action falling outside the powers of a court. According to AG Rantos, the same reasoning may apply to arbitration tribunals since they are third-party bodies in relation to public authorities. 

The AG therefore proposed that the Court uphold the appeals, set aside the General Court’s judgment and annul Article 1 of the Commission decision on the ground that the existence of an economic advantage had not been established. 

For more information, see the AG’s opinion.